In a significant ruling in an illegal appointment case, the Gauhati High Court has held that an appointment made solely on the basis of an oral instruction, without any advertisement or proper recruitment process, cannot be regularised merely because the individual has served for a long period.
The court further observed that an employee appointed through such an irregular process cannot reasonably claim pensionary and other retirement benefits on the basis of that appointment.
The ruling was delivered by Justice Manish Choudhury while hearing a writ petition filed by Selim Uddin Barbhuiya, who was employed as a Lower Division Assistant (LDA) in the Education Department of Hailakandi district.
Barbhuiya had approached the Gauhati High Court for the fourth time, seeking pensionary benefits. However, the court strongly disapproved of his repeated attempts to seek relief through successive petitions, describing the latest move as an act of “sheer audacity”.
Justice Choudhury also termed the petition an “abuse of the process of law”.
The court observed that a person cannot claim pensionary benefits without a valid appointment made through the prescribed recruitment procedure. It further emphasised that long years of service alone cannot confer legal validity on an appointment made without following the requisite procedure.
Taking serious note of the repeated litigation, the High Court imposed a cost of Rs 25,000 on the petitioner for abusing the judicial process.
The court directed Barbhuiya to deposit the amount with the Registry of the Gauhati High Court within one month. It further ordered that the amount be utilised for the Gauhati High Court Bar Association.
With this order, the Gauhati High Court dismissed Barbhuiya’s fourth writ petition, reiterating the importance of following due legal procedures in public appointments and rejecting claims for pensionary benefits based on an invalid appointment.
